(Illegal) Music Downloads
It's time I weighed in on the P2P debate.
Recently, I purchased an album put out by EMI. The artist in question is not important, suffice to say that I like this artist very much. I'm talking about the kind of "liking" where you think that if you knew the person, you would be best friends. Anyway, I'm a really sucker for album sleeves, especially the bit at the end where the artist goes through a list of names of people that they would like to thank. Sometimes they throw in a little something extra - you know, like a poem. My most recent purchase had no poem. It had something else:
What!?
When I first read that, it was late and I was tired. It took me by surprise. I thought I knew this person. How could he think that? I pictured that puppet from N.E.R.D. Surely, he's nothing like that guy! After rereading that passage, I became suspicious. After a little research I was able to confirm that the words were not his own. Well, to be fair, six of them were. Can you guess which? I'll tell you: "Thank You for buying this music."
Slotted in neatly after the artists comments is this act of commerical ventriloquism: The EMI anti-piracy statement. A little background...
I discovered this artist listed on Pitchfork's Best New Music 2005. I'd heard one of his tracks and thought the album warranted a listen. So I went out and bought it. Actually, no, I didn't do that. I downloaded it, and fell in love with it. I added it to my "Must Buy" list and a couple of months later, when I was out CD shopping I asked if it was in stock. Unforunately, it wasn't. Can you order it in for me please? Sure, but it will take 3 months. I paused, and replied, "Sure."
What I'm trying to say is that the only reason I have the CD next to me today is because I "stole" it from the internet and later decided that it was worthy of a purchase. Perhaps you would like to draw an analogy? Something like, "Would you steal a car and later return to the store to buy it?" Well of course I wouldn't. I would be arrested for stealing a car. Music is nothing like a car, but lets work with it. "Would you buy a car without trying it out?"
I am in that category of people who download albums because they want to take them for a test drive. A month long test drive, at least. If I like an album, I'll buy it. I promise. If I don't like it, then I'm sorry, but you don't get your money, better luck next time. And no, I will not necessarily delete it if I decide that I don't like it. Obviously if I hate it isn't going to hang around. But when it comes to those so-so albums, who knows, maybe after another month I'll decide that I actually do like the album and the record company (and artist) will end up getting their money after all.
Sure, some people don't have the same policy of honesty. They download music without the intent to buy. Look at it this way, if they had to pay for it - they probably wouldn't.
Recently, I purchased an album put out by EMI. The artist in question is not important, suffice to say that I like this artist very much. I'm talking about the kind of "liking" where you think that if you knew the person, you would be best friends. Anyway, I'm a really sucker for album sleeves, especially the bit at the end where the artist goes through a list of names of people that they would like to thank. Sometimes they throw in a little something extra - you know, like a poem. My most recent purchase had no poem. It had something else:
Thank you for buying this music. This recording and artwork are protected by copyright law. Using internet services to distribute copyrighted music, giving away illegal copies of discs or lending discs to others for them to copy is illegal and does not support those involved in making this piece of music - especially the artist. By carrying out any of these action it has the same effect as stealing music.
What!?
When I first read that, it was late and I was tired. It took me by surprise. I thought I knew this person. How could he think that? I pictured that puppet from N.E.R.D. Surely, he's nothing like that guy! After rereading that passage, I became suspicious. After a little research I was able to confirm that the words were not his own. Well, to be fair, six of them were. Can you guess which? I'll tell you: "Thank You for buying this music."
Slotted in neatly after the artists comments is this act of commerical ventriloquism: The EMI anti-piracy statement. A little background...
I discovered this artist listed on Pitchfork's Best New Music 2005. I'd heard one of his tracks and thought the album warranted a listen. So I went out and bought it. Actually, no, I didn't do that. I downloaded it, and fell in love with it. I added it to my "Must Buy" list and a couple of months later, when I was out CD shopping I asked if it was in stock. Unforunately, it wasn't. Can you order it in for me please? Sure, but it will take 3 months. I paused, and replied, "Sure."
What I'm trying to say is that the only reason I have the CD next to me today is because I "stole" it from the internet and later decided that it was worthy of a purchase. Perhaps you would like to draw an analogy? Something like, "Would you steal a car and later return to the store to buy it?" Well of course I wouldn't. I would be arrested for stealing a car. Music is nothing like a car, but lets work with it. "Would you buy a car without trying it out?"
I am in that category of people who download albums because they want to take them for a test drive. A month long test drive, at least. If I like an album, I'll buy it. I promise. If I don't like it, then I'm sorry, but you don't get your money, better luck next time. And no, I will not necessarily delete it if I decide that I don't like it. Obviously if I hate it isn't going to hang around. But when it comes to those so-so albums, who knows, maybe after another month I'll decide that I actually do like the album and the record company (and artist) will end up getting their money after all.
Sure, some people don't have the same policy of honesty. They download music without the intent to buy. Look at it this way, if they had to pay for it - they probably wouldn't.

